Best Cake Cutting Knives Review: Which One Would You Choose?

Did you know?

Cakes require different cutting knives compared to other foods in the kitchen.

Cake knives are specially designed for slicing cakes in smooth and clean cuts.

These blades come in two types; serrated and non-serrated.

Serrated cake knives are used for cutting less-dense cakes whose textures are harder on the outside and softer in the inside.

Non-serrated blades are perfect for cutting cakes with little texture difference between the inside and outside such as a cheesecake.

AT A GLANCE: MY TOP 5 PICKS FOR THE BEST CAKE CUTTING KNIVES
  1. MY TOP PICK: Darnell Nehemiah Cake Knife
  2. Chef Owl Professional Pie Server Set
  3. LEGERM Straight Icing Spatula Baking Set
  4. OXO 1248980 Good Grips Cupcake Icing Knife
  5. Wilton Icing Spatula, 13-Inch, Angled Cake Spatula

Related:

What is a Cake Knife Called?

A cake knife is also referred to as a cake shovel, pie knife or cake slicer.

Some of these knives have serrated edges while others have straight edges.

Should You Cut a Cake When it is Hot or Cold?

It is advisable to cut a cake after it has cooled completely so that it is firm and does not tear or crack.

Cutting a cake while it is still hot makes it impossible to have smooth and clean cuts due to tearing and cracking of the cake.

Best Cake Cutting Knives Review

Product imagesProduct namesEditor's ratingPrice
Darnell Nehemiah Stainless Steel Cake Knife Plastic HandleDarnell Nehemiah 10Inch/12Inch Stainless Steel Cake Knife4.9See Latest Price
Chef Owl Professional Pie Server SetChef Owl Professional Pie Server Set4.8See Latest Price
LEGERM Straight Icing Spatula Stainless Steel Baking SetLEGERM Straight Icing Spatula Stainless Steel Baking Set4.7See Latest Price
OXO 1248980 Good Grips Cupcake Icing KnifeOXO 1248980 Good Grips Cupcake Icing Knife4.6See Latest Price
Wilton Icing Spatula, 13-Inch, Angled Cake SpatulaWilton Icing Spatula, 13-Inch, Angled Cake Spatula4.5See Latest Price

Darnell Nehemiah Plastic Handle Cake Knife

Darnell Nehemiah Stainless Steel Cake Knife Plastic Handle

See Latest Price

The sturdiness and sharpness of this knife with a plastic handle are some of the main reasons why the knife is a favorite baking tool for most bakers.

The blade is perfect for layering, trimming, leveling, and serving cakes. The blade is long (10”/12”) for easy cutting and slicing through different cake sizes.

Multi-purpose design 

This Stainless-steel spatula features a multi-purpose design with a smooth surface for spreading butter, applying scribble, decorating fondant cakes, cutting a cake, and applying cream on bread and cakes.

In addition to this, the serrated blade is sharp and hence can be used for slicing bread and portioning cakes.

The fine polishing on the steel blade makes the spatula resistant to corrosion, discoloration, and scratching.

PP Plastic Handle 

Unlike other cake spatulas that come with wooden handles that tend to get damaged by water, the handle in this spatula is made from a solid PP plastic.

This plastic is not only resistant to damage by moisture/water but is also impervious to heat changes in the kitchen.

As such, the handle is comfortable to hold all the time; whether cold or hot.

Pros:

  1. Plastic handle with a comfortable grip
  2. Multi-functional teeth knife for slicing bread and cakes
  3. High-quality steel that is resistant to corrosion and staining
  4. High strength blade that is equally durable
  5. Long blade for varying cake sizes

Cons:

  1. Not dishwasher friendly

Chef Owl Professional Pie Server Set

Chef Owl Professional Pie Server Set

See Latest Price

The Professional Pie Server Set is an all-round stainless-steel set that includes a cutting spatula with a serving knife. The set is ideal for serving pizza, cake, pies, lasagna, and desserts.

The flexible serving spatula digs into a variety of pies easily without crushing or damaging the pie.

The most amazing feature about this set is that the spatula and knife are dishwasher safe.

Sharp serrated edges

The edges of the pie server and cake knife in this set are serrated and extremely sharp.

These blades cut through pizza, pies, cake, and flatbread easily and effortlessly. You do not require to exert intense pressure or force when cutting with these edges.

What is more amazing about the edges is that they provide smooth and clean cuts. The flexible blades are easy to control for precise and accurate cutting.

Unique design and finish

The Professional Pie Server Set boasts of a high-end design that has an excellent beauty and décor aspect.

The beautiful mirrored metallic finish on the blades complements the elegance of the modern teal handle. This combination brings about an amazing appearance in the kitchen.

The distinctive blue color of the handles makes it easy for the blades to stand out from other blades in your knife collection.

Pros:

  1. Flexible serving spatula
  2. Sharp serrated blades that cut through bread and cake easily
  3. Beautiful design with an elegant finish
  4. Dishwasher safe
  5. Excellent control for precision and accuracy

Cons:

  1. The sharp edges can easily inflict injuries if mishandled

Legerm Straight Icing Spatula Baking Set

LEGERM Straight Icing Spatula Stainless Steel Baking Set

See Latest Price

The Straight Icing Spatula Stainless Steel Baking Set is the ideal cake decoration and frosting set for a professional cake specialist who bakes different sizes of cakes often.

The three spatulas in the set feature varying lengths (6”,8” & 10”) for decorating different cupcake sizes.

The spatulas do a clean, smooth, and even job whether you are decorating a small or large cupcake.

Ergonomic wooden handle 

The wooden handle in this spatula set is ergonomically designed for easy and comfortable gripping when icing cupcakes.

The softwood feels nice in the hands and as such, you are not likely to get any blisters even when you use the spatulas for long sessions.

The lightweight handle has a hole for easy storage by hanging it on a nail or knife strip.

Durable stainless-steel blades 

The flexible and durable stainless-steel blades in this icing spatula set are made from premium quality steel. This steel boasts of excellent durability, resistance to corrosion and rusting, and incredible resilience.

As such, the blades hold well against normal wear and tear thereby being efficient and dependable throughout their lives.

These blades are perfect for tasks such as icing desserts, carrying cakes & pizzas, frosting pastry, crepes, cookies & cupcakes, and cutting curds.

Pros:

  1. Multi-purpose blades for use in the kitchen
  2. Wooden handles with a perfect grip for optimal comfort and control
  3. Flexible and highly durable steel blades
  4. Comes with a storage hole on the handle
  5. Compact spatula set with varying blade sizes

Cons:

  1. The coating on the handle easily comes off when scratched

OXO 1248980 Good Grips Cupcake Icing Knife

OXO 1248980 Good Grips Cupcake Icing Knife

See Latest Price

If you are looking for an icing knife for icing and decorating your cupcakes, look no further than at the OXO 1248980 Good Grips Icing Knife.

The knife comes with an angled blade for keeping the countertop clean when icing cakes.

The best thing about this icing knife is that it is multi-purpose and can be used for other tasks around the kitchen such as applying butter on bread slices.

Flexible steel blade 

The blade in this icing knife is stiff yet flexible for providing excellent control when icing the cake.

This flexibility also comes in handy when you are icing cakes with unique shapes that are impossible to ice using a standard kitchen knife.

The even edges in the blade allow for even coats thereby bringing about uniformity and evenness on the cake’s surface.

Contoured handle with a firm grip 

The soft handle of this icing knife is contoured for a comfortable and firm grip.

This in turn allows you to have the best control and precision when icing cupcakes or even smaller cakes. The handle is water-resistant and not affected by changes in heat.

Therefore, it is perfect for use in a normal kitchen setting or bakery where temperatures are high.

Pros:

  1. Smooth blade edges that provide for even coats
  2. Angled blade for keeping the countertop clean
  3. Comfortable and firm grip
  4. Flexible blade for better icing
  5. Perfect size and shape for cupcake icing and decoration

Cons:

  1. Not dishwasher friendly

Wilton Icing Spatula, 13” Angled Cake Spatula

Wilton Icing Spatula, 13-Inch, Angled Cake Spatula

See Latest Price

The Wilton Icing Spatula is a massive cake blade designed for smoothing ice on a cake while ensuring that your fingers do not get in the icing.

Using a standard knife for frosting and applying ice on cakes not only creates uneven ice patches on the cake but also leads to wastage of the icing.

The long length of this spatula makes it possible to use the blade with varying sizes of cakes. As such, you can even use it for your home kitchen or even in a commercial bakery.

Ergonomic handle 

Accuracy and precision are important aspects when it comes to frosting and icing cakes. This is why the 13-inch angled cake spatula by Wilton features an ergonomic handle.

This handle is comfortable to hold in the hands without straining or creating fatigue to the hands. The plastic handle is impervious to heat and resistant to moisture.

Therefore, it is built for use in a typical bakery with the spatula’s durability and efficiency making it a great addition in any kitchen.

Stainless steel construction

The blade in the Wilton Icing Spatula is made using high-quality stainless steel. This type of steel is resistant to corrosion, rusting, and extreme wear and tear.

The 33-centimeter steel blade is easy to hand wash and also exhibits unique resistance to scratching and denting. As such, it remains in a pristine condition throughout its life.

Pros:

  1. Stainless steel construction
  2. Long blade length for enhanced application
  3. Resistant to heat and water/moisture
  4. A comfortable ergonomic handle
  5. Easy to handwash

Cons:

  1. The plastic handle feels light and not solid

How to Choose a Good Knife for Cutting & Slicing Cake

cake cutting knives

Choosing the right cake knife will determine how easy it will be for you to make clean and smooth cuts using the knife. Your choice of a knife will also determine how durable and reliable the knife will be in the long run. Here are a few tips on identifying the right cake knife:

Consider length

It is always recommendable to opt for a blade that is a few inches longer than the food you intend to cut with the knife. The ideal length of a cake knife to settle for is between 10 and 14 inches. For home use, a 10” cake knife will work best for you but use in a commercial kitchen, 14 inches is an ideal choice. It is worth noting that longer blades are more complex to control but with time, it becomes easy to control the blade for precise cuts.

Choose blade material

The material of the blade determines the number of aspects including sharpness and durability. The best cake knives have high-carbon steel since this type of steel is sturdy, durable, retains sharpness for long, and is easy to sharpen. However, this steel type is considerably expensive. Stainless steel is yet another excellent choice for cake knives.

Consider the brand

You should also consider the brand of choice when it comes to cake knives. This is because you should only limit your search to brands that are popular for designing high-end blades that are durable, efficient, and reliable. Such brands usually come in handy in the kitchen due to their long-lasting construction.

Budget options

Shopping for a cake knife without a budget can be detrimental to your financial wellbeing. You may end up spending a high amount of money on a cake knife and consequently incur financial constraints. With a budget, it becomes easy to identify the best quality cake knife that is affordable to you. This will, in turn, give you the best value for your hard-earned cash.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why does my cake fall apart when I cut it?

If your cake falls apart when cutting or slicing it and you had used an all-purpose flour when baking, the high gluten content in the flour makes the cake moist and crumbly hence will fall apart when cutting.

How long is a cake knife?

Cake knives come with varying lengths. The average length of these blades is 10-14 inches. However, it is possible to get cake knives that are longer or shorter than this length range.

How does a cake slicer work?

A cake slicer comprises a control platform, a knife, and a housing unit where you place the cake for slicing.

The knife (in some cake slicers it is in the form of wire) is connected to the control platform and turns in a consistent motion over or through the cake for leveling and making even slices. The slicer comes with alignment tabs for varying the size of slices.

Conclusion

A cake knife is a great investment for a budding baker or even a professional chef who occasionally prepares cakes in the kitchen.

The majority of these knives double as bread knives due to their serrated cutting edges. Therefore, when you buy a cake knife, you get two blades for the cost of one.

Cake blades are increasingly becoming a must-have utensil in the kitchen especially for people venturing into baking as a hobby.

Further reading:

The Best Way to Cut Cake

How to Cut a Round Cake